Home / After an accident

How is fault decided after a car accident?

Do not admit fault at the scene. Your insurer may contact the other drivers, their insurers and any witnesses, and investigate who was at fault. If police attend, their report may be important if there is a dispute about fault. If it cannot be agreed, it can be resolved through the courts.

Who decides who was at fault?

After you claim, your insurer may contact any other drivers, their insurers and any witnesses who saw the accident. It may also investigate to confirm what happened and who was at fault.

If it cannot be agreed, it can be resolved through the courts. A court may decide that both drivers were partly at fault.

Should you admit fault at the scene?

No. Victoria Legal Aid says not to admit that an accident was your fault. You may not be qualified to decide this, and the admission could be used as evidence against you if there is a dispute.

What information helps show what happened?

Moneysmart lists the information your insurer may need:

  • The location of the accident
  • A description of what happened and any damage to cars or property, with photos
  • A police report number, if police attended
  • The details of the tow truck company, if one attended
  • The contact details of any witnesses

See what details to swap and write down at the scene.

What does a police report do?

When police attend, they investigate by talking to the drivers and any witnesses, and write a report. Victoria Legal Aid says this report may be important if there is a dispute about who was at fault.

Police may not attend unless someone has been injured.

Read when you must report a car accident to police.

What if you are not sure who was at fault?

Call us on 1300 026 598 and tell us what happened. We will tell you if we can help.

Sources

Published 18 November 2026. This page gives general information. It is not legal or insurance advice.

Contact

Phone: 1300 026 598

Email: info@ultradrive.com.au

Location: Melbourne, Victoria

We answer 24 hours a day, 7 days. Had an accident that was not your fault? Fill in the vehicle claim form.

Had an accident that was not your fault?

Call 1300 026 598 Make a claim