How is a replacement vehicle different from a rental car?
An accident replacement vehicle is for drivers who were not at fault. It is like for like, delivered to you, and its cost is claimed from the at fault driver’s insurer. With an ordinary rental you hire and pay for the car yourself. A hire car through your own insurer depends on what your policy includes.
What is an accident replacement vehicle?
A like-for-like replacement vehicle, delivered to you, while your car is off the road. It is for drivers who were not at fault in the accident.
You are covered to the day you pick up your car from the repairer.
What does like for like mean?
A vehicle broadly equivalent to your own car. In 2021 the High Court of Australia found that a not at fault driver can recover the reasonable cost of hiring a broadly equivalent vehicle.
How is an ordinary rental different?
With an ordinary rental you hire the car and pay for it yourself. Consumer Affairs Victoria says rental car contracts include terms about damage and your liabilities.
Any insurance or excess fee you pay only reduces the amount you may have to pay if the car is damaged, usually to between $3,000 and $5,000. The limits are higher for a prestige car.
What about a hire car through your own insurer?
Moneysmart lists car hire as one of the extras some car insurance policies include. The kind of protection you have depends on what your policy says, so check it or ask your insurer.
What should you check on any hire car?
Consumer Affairs Victoria suggests:
- Inspect the car thoroughly, including under the bumper bars, the doors and inside
- Ask for a condition report
- Consider taking photos of the car before you return it
- Be there when it is inspected
The hire company must give you a car that meets the terms of your agreement, including any promises it made before you entered into it.
Who pays for an UltraDrive replacement vehicle?
The cost is claimed from the at fault driver’s insurer. We make the claim and deal with the insurer for you.
Read who pays for a replacement vehicle when you were not at fault, or call 1300 026 598 and ask what happens if their insurer refuses.
Related pages
Sources
- High Court of Australia: Arsalan v Rixon; Nguyen v Cassim [2021] HCA 40
- Consumer Affairs Victoria: car hire
- Moneysmart: choosing car insurance
- Victoria Legal Aid: driving, accidents and insurance
Published 18 November 2026. This page gives general information. It is not legal or insurance advice.
Contact
We answer 24 hours a day, 7 days. Had an accident that was not your fault? Fill in the vehicle claim form.